Last updated: January 30, 2023
Accessibility is a core value and design component of Fulcrum. As part of the ongoing development of Fulcrum, we work to make the platform and its content inclusive, accessible, and usable for all readers.
Fulcrum aims to meet the latest WCAG 2 AA Standards (currently WCAG 2.1 AA) in two ways:
- Developing a platform with infrastructure that meets web accessibility guidelines and includes accessibility features.
- Creating and sharing resources that help publishers produce accessible content.
We report Fulcrum's compliance with WCAG 2.0 and Section 508 in a Voluntary Product Accessibility Template (VPAT®) Version 2.4 INT. We report content compliance in collection specific VPATs.
Accessibility features, compatibility, and known issues are also summarized on this page.
If you need to be provided with an accessible version of a book or need other assistance using the platform, please email firstname.lastname@example.org.
If you would like to report an issue, share general comments, suggestions, or other ideas, please use our feedback form.
Accessibility Timeline and Roadmap
In January 2023, several VPAT®s were revised and updated including the core master VPAT for Fulcrum.
In January 2022, the Fulcrum team upgraded its time-based media player, AblePlayer, to a more current version to improve support for video description and interactive transcripts.
We released Audio/Video Guidelines for accessibility, ensuring authors have instructions for creating accessible multimedia.
We updated the core version behind the Fulcrum PDF Reader to improve and fix accessibility and other issues. We improved focus states, focus orders, and table display in the Fulcrum Reader and added ARIA labels to improve display of DOIs.
We revised VPAT®s and Roadmaps for ACLS HEB, as well as continued a project to reformat fixed layout page-image ebooks into more structured and accessible PDF formats.
In December 2022, we modified our EPUB workflow to ensure that downloaded EPUBs do not fail EPUBCheck and remediated over 80 UMP EBC EPUBs to add long descriptions to complex images.
In June 2021, we updated all VPAT®s to Version 2.4 INT and worked with the DAISY Consortium to have the Fulcrum Reader tested with NVDA and Microsoft Edge Read Aloud.
In December 2021, the Fulcrum team held two sprints focused on usability and accessibility improvements to the platform, resolving several outstanding issues around semantic encoding and screen reader support that had been identified in previous accessibility evaluations.
From January to March 2020, in collaboration with Michigan State University Usability and Accessibility Research Consulting (archived site), Fulcrum was tested by assistive technology and limited dexterity users. User testing helped identify usability and accessibility issues, specifically with the Fulcrum Reader, which we are working to address.
In March and May 2020, we worked to update our Voluntary Product Assessment Template from 2.1 to VPAT® Version 2.3 INT. In addition, we released collection-specific VPAT®s for the University of Michigan E-Book Collection, the ACLS Humanities E-Book Collection, and the BAR Digital Collection.
Over the course of 2020, we released several accessibility improvements to Fulcrum including: accessible link labels, a more usable and accessible search and browse experience, improved color contrast, and support for transcripts and visual descriptions of audio and video content hosted on Fulcrum.
In August and September 2019, the Fulcrum team collaborated with the DAISY Consortium to have the Fulcrum Reader evaluated for http://epubtest.org. Several accessibility and usability issues and best practices were identified and Fulcrum developers are working to address identified issues. We will continue to work with the DAISY Consortium to have future versions of the Fulcrum Reader evaluated.
In August and September 2019, the University of Michigan Press Ebook Collection received a high-level accessibility evaluation and a PDF accessibility evaluation. These evaluations were conducted by Deque on behalf of the Big Ten Academic Alliance (BTAA) E-Resources Committee. The resulting reports were published alongside our response. Several new accessibility issues were identified and are currently being addressed by the Fulcrum development team.
In January 2019, Fulcrum released the Fulcrum EPUB Specification.
From June to August 2018, Michigan Publishing and Fulcrum worked with Luke Kudryashov through the Rackham Public Engagement Fellowship program to conduct an accessibility evaluation of the Fulcrum platform. Building on the previous usability testing, Luke completed a VPAT 2.1 by testing the platform with the use of assistive technology, documented additional accessibility and usability issues, and also worked with Emma DiPasquale, the Fulcrum community manager, to provide more detailed accessibility documentation for the Fulcrum website.
From January to March 2018, in collaboration with Michigan State University Usability and Accessibility Research Consulting (archived site), Fulcrum was tested by assistive technology users, identifying usability and accessibility issues, which we are actively working to address. Some of these include: usability issues for assistive technology; missing image descriptions for assistive technology navigation; and missing captions and transcripts for video and audio content.
Compatibility with Keyboards and Screen Readers
Screen Reader Compatibility
Fulcrum should be compatible with most major screen readers. It is optimized for use with NVDA in Firefox. New features are tested with NVDA in Firefox and VoiceOver in Safari. Fulcrum should be compatible with recent versions of the following screen readers:
The site is also compatible with:
- basic operating system screen magnifiers and contrast settings
- accessibility browser extensions, such as Read Aloud (text to speech), Zoom Text Only (magnifier), and High Contrast for Chrome
- speech recognition software
- operating system speech packages
For readers using NVDA:
- In the Fulcrum Reader, alt-text image descriptions will be read when the embedded image is selected via the TAB key, but will not be read automatically via continuous reading. Alt-text image descriptions can be accessed by selecting the embedded image via keyboard controls or by following the link to the full image media page.
- In the Fulcrum Reader, when searching inside the text of a book and following a search result, the matched term in the text is indicated on the page only through visual highlighting of the matched text, but the excerpts and chapter locations are accessible through screen reader technology.
- In the Fulcrum Reader, text selection for highlighting or note taking does not work as expected.
- On book title pages, “Table of Contents” is the default tab. To get to other tabs on that page, navigate to the “Table of Contents” heading and press the right arrow key.
- On resources pages, “Info” is the default tab. To get to others tabs, navigate to the “Info” heading and press the right arrow key.
For readers using VoiceOver:
- When the focus in the Fulcrum Reader is on a piece of embedded content such as a video or image, the VoiceOver rotor only recognizes the media controls as links. To access the other links and menu buttons through the rotor, navigate away from the embedded piece of media first.
For readers using Microsoft Edge Read Aloud:
- In the Fulcrum Reader, the visual display of text does not continue to scroll when Read Aloud reaches the bottom of the page.
- In the Fulcrum Reader, it is not possible to adjust the emphasis styles in Read Aloud.
For readers playing time-based media in resources or ebooks:
- As of January 2022, the current version of AblePlayer on Fulcrum has a known issue where audio descriptions can auto-play when users activate descriptions to be read aloud by the player and navigate book pages. Turning off the read aloud function of the descriptions will resolve this issue.
For readers using Dragon NaturallySpeaking:
- Filter buttons and content on the Search and Browse Books page do not respond to voice command navigation.
- In the Fulcrum Reader, all of the pages, and media content such as videos, audio, and images should be accessible via standard keyboard controls only (no use of a mouse required).
- Standard keyboard controls include:
- TAB to move through links and buttons
- SHIFT+TAB to go back to a previous link or button
- ENTER to select
- Left and right arrow keys in the Fulcrum Reader provide shortcuts for easy page flipping or scrolling.
- Using scroll mode in the Fulcrum Reader, Page Up and Page Down and up and down arrow keys also allow for page scrolling.
- The default video player shortcuts are as follows:
- Alt + Control + p or spacebar = Play/Pause
- Alt + Control + s = Restart
- Alt + Control + r = Rewind
- Alt + Control + f = Forward
- Alt + Control + v or 1-9 = Volume
- Alt + Control + m = Mute/Unmute
- Alt + Control + c = Hide captions
- Escape = Close current dialog or popup menu
- For certain content, users can choose between page-by-page and scroll view in the Fulcrum Reader. To switch views, select the Preferences and Settings button and choose your preferred Display mode.
- AblePlayer video and audio player has the capability for captions, audio descriptions, and transcripts, though not all publishers may provide these features. The caption font, size, color, and location can be adjusted in the player settings. Captions and transcripts are available when provided by the publisher. As of January 2022, the current version of AblePlayer on Fulcrum has a known issue where audio descriptions can auto-play based on the time codes when users activate descriptions to be read aloud by the player. Turning off the read aloud function of the descriptions will resolve this issue.
- Image descriptions are enabled for screen readers through alt-text attributes (when provided by publisher).
- While there is no built-in text-to-speech feature, screen readers and text-to-speech browser extensions such as Read Aloud for Chrome should work with the Fulcrum Reader as well as all of the book, publisher, and media pages.
For readers with low vision:
- In the Fulcrum Reader, a book's text can be zoomed up to 400% through the Preferences and Settings menu. Switching to scroll view is recommended when enlarging the text as this will shift the text from two columns to one.
- Operating system text zoom and font accessibility settings and browser extensions such as Zoom Text Only for Chrome should work with all of the other text on book, publisher, and media pages, as well as the menu bars in the Fulcrum Reader.
- The video player offers a full screen view and the image viewer offers a zoom function.
- The video player supports user control of caption settings, including toggle, position, font, size, text color, background, and opacity as well as user control of audio description (when captions and audio descriptions provided by publisher).
- Operating system contrast accessibility features and browser extensions such as High Contrast for Chrome should work with the Fulcrum Reader in addition to all other Fulcrum pages.
Accessibility of Content on Fulcrum
Fulcrum provides hosting for a number of different publishers and we are a signatory of the Accessible Book Consortium's Charter for Accessible Publishing. Accessible content is the primary responsibility of each publisher yet to uphold our accessibility commitments to the ABC, we work with publishers to support and improve the accessibility of their content. Below you will find a list of accessibility features and known content issues in large collections hosted on Fulcrum.
ACLS Humanities E-Book
ACLS HEB Voluntary Product Accessibility Template (VPAT®) Version 2.4 INT
In addition to the ACLS HEB VPAT®, ACLS HEB has made available an Accessibility Conformance and Remediation Roadmap (October 2022) which describes timelines, development plans, and workarounds for issues identified in the VPAT®.
There are three types of book content within the ACLS Humanities E-Book (HEB). The type informs the accessibility of that content:
- EPUBs created by reformatting print to digital and include page scans and uncorrected OCR text. When read in the Fulcrum Reader, the uncorrected OCR can be accessed by adjusting the Settings and Preferences to use the text renditions. These titles are available for chapter download only in PDF format. The PDF downloads do not include the uncorrected OCR.
- EPUBs created by reformatting print to digital and include reflowable, structured text. The content of these EPUBs are compatible with assistive technology. These titles are not available for download.
- Beginning in 2020, PDFs provided by publishers include OCR or born-digital text, bookmarks, but do not include structural markup and tagging. These titles are available for chapter download only in PDF format. PDF watermarks applied to each page of the downloaded file are read aloud by screenreaders and assistive technology.
ACLS HEB titles do not contain textual descriptions of images.
To request remediation of any content in the ACLS HEB, it is recommended to first contact the publisher of that title. The publisher information can either be found in the Get Citation tool in the Fulcrum Reader, or found on the title landing page beneath the author name, and may include a link to the publisher's webpage. If you cannot find the publisher information, please send an email with the title of the content, your preferred format, and the URL to email@example.com.
University of Michigan Press Ebook Collection
UMP EBC Voluntary Product Accessibility Template (VPAT®) Version 2.4 INT
In addition to the UMP EBC VPAT®, more detail is made available in an Accessibility Conformance and Remediation Roadmap (January 2023) which describes timelines, development plans, and workarounds for issues identified in the VPAT®.
All titles in the University of Michigan Press Ebook Collection (UMP EBC) are available for download in EPUB and PDF formats, with the exception of a handful of titles only available in one format. In all cases, we recommend the EPUB format as the accessible format – all EPUBs in the UMP EBC have been designed following the Fulcrum EPUB Specification, designed to ensure compatibility with assistive technology and are more likely to contain image descriptions. However, we recognize not all print disabled users prefer EPUB and will remediate PDF files with textual descriptions of images upon request.
All titles published after 2019 contain at least basic textual descriptions of images, however these descriptions are only contained within EPUB files. All titles published in 2022 and after contain complete textual descriptions through a combination of alt text and long/extended descriptions. All audio and video associated with books produced after 2018 have transcripts or captions available. Some supplemental content has been reformatted from print to digital and may not contain Optical Character Recognition text. If OCR text has been included it has not been corrected.
Beginning with titles published in 2021, most titles are certified accessible by the Benetech Global Certified Accessible program and meet WCAG AA. Titles that are not certified accessible by Benetech are indicated as such in the EPUB metadata.
To request remediation of any content in the UMP EBC, please send an email with the title of the content, your preferred format, and the URL to firstname.lastname@example.org.
It is the goal of Lever Press that every title containing illustrations also include textual descriptions of those images, and that audio and video content associated with titles include transcripts and captions.
Lever Press titles, while open access and freely available, are not available for download.
To request remediation or a file download of any Lever Press title, send and email with the title of the content, your preferred format, and the URL to email@example.com.
BAR Digital Collection
BAR Digital Collection Voluntary Product Accessibility Template (VPAT®) Version 2.4 INT
To request remediation of any content in the BAR Digital Collection, please send an email with the title of the content, your preferred format, and the URL to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Resources for Creating Accessible Content
There are several resources the Fulcrum team has developed to assist publishers in the creation of accessible content. These resources, as well as others on the web are detailed below.
- Describing Visual Resources Toolkit
Funded by the Kress Foundation, this resource was developed by the University of Michigan Press in partnership with leaders and experts in the fields of accessibility for libraries, museums, and archives. The resource aims to help authors, publishers, and others develop a best practice for describing images in the humanities and social sciences.
- Fulcrum EPUB Specification
In partnership with Apex Covantage we developed and released a specification for the creation of highly accessible and Fulcrum compliant EPUBs. The specification was released under an Apache 2.0 License and can be re-used in-house by publisher's production teams, or supplied to vendors that assist in the creation of a publisher's ebook files.
- Accessibility and Publishing, by Stephanie S. Rosen
Written by University of Michigan Library's Accessibility Specialist, this open access ebook is a primer for publishers looking to gain an orientation to the complex landscape of accessible publishing in the scholarly ecosystem.
- Book Industry Study Group Guide to Accessible Publishing and Cheat Sheets
A live, up-to-date guide for publishers looking to start making their content accessible.
- Audio/Video Guidelines for Michigan Publishing/U-M Press Authors
A live, up-to-date accessibility guide for authors and publishers who have time-based media that will be hosted on the Fulcrum platform, developed by Michigan Publishing's Accessibility Working Group.